Cannabinoids and Terpenes
HomeReferenceCannabinoids and Terpenes
Reference · Chemistry

Cannabinoids and Terpenes

The plant makes cannabinoids and terpenes, two groups of compounds, in the same small gland, as acids, on one pathway. This paper tells you where the plant makes each group and how the quantity of each group decreases after harvest. It gives the facts about each compound and corrects incorrect claims about it. It also tells you the decisions of the grower that change the numbers. After you read this paper, you will know how to read a COA. You will know the levers that have an effect and the claims of suppliers that have no data.

Reference10 diagrams18 sources~24 min to read
Start here

Purpose and scope

Two groups of molecules cause the differences in the quality of flower, in the results of a lab test and in the price of flower. The first group is cannabinoids (the potency). The second group is terpenes (the aroma and flavor). The plant makes the two groups in the same small gland on the surface of the flower. This gland is the trichome. Almost all tasks of a grower increase or decrease the quantity of compounds in this gland.

This paper tells you where the plant makes the compounds and how the plant assembles them. It gives the facts about each compound and corrects incorrect claims about it. It tells you how the compounds decrease in quantity after harvest, and it tells you the levers that you have.

Cannabis contains many more compounds than the labels on products show. Reports show more than 500 different compounds in cannabis. Of these compounds, 125 are cannabinoids and approximately 120 are terpenes[1]. Approximately six cannabinoids and eight terpenes are the most important in flower products. When you know these compounds, you can read each COA, each list of cultivars and each claim about a product.

CannabinoidA group of compounds that almost no other plant makes (THC, CBD, CBG and related compounds). The compounds have an effect on the receptor systems of a person. It is possible that the plant makes them for protection. They give the crop most of its value.
TerpeneSmall oil molecules that evaporate easily. They give plants their aroma, for example the aroma of pine, citrus, pepper and hops. Many other plants also make terpenes. Terpenes are all of the aroma and flavor of flower. They evaporate much more easily than cannabinoids.
TrichomeThe resin gland on flowers and sugar leaves. The gland has a head on a stalk. You can see the glands as the ‘frost’ on the flower. The plant makes the two groups of compounds in the head, and the compounds stay in the head.
ResinThe tacky oil in the heads of trichomes. It contains cannabinoid acids, terpenes and waxes. The potency and the flavor of flower are in the resin. Thus the value of flower is its resin.
THCATetrahydrocannabinolic acid. THCA is the acid of THC, and the plant makes THCA and not THC. THCA does not cause intoxication until heat changes it (decarboxylation).
DecarboxylationThe step in which heat removes a carboxyl group (–COOH) from a cannabinoid acid. The reaction releases CO₂ as a gas, and the molecule that stays is active and neutral. Heat causes the reaction. After the gas is in the air, the reaction cannot occur in the opposite direction. The short name is ‘decarb’.
ChemotypeThe type of cannabinoid ratio of a plant. The types are THC-dominant, a balance of THC and CBD, CBD-dominant, CBG-dominant and without cannabinoids. The type is in the genes of the plant from germination. No task of the grower changes it.
COACertificate of Analysis. The COA is the lab report that gives the cannabinoid content and the terpene content. It shows the result of each decision in this paper.
Limits of this paper

This paper does not tell you the effect of a compound on a person. It gives each effect only as a report or as an effect for which investigations are in progress. Most of the data about effects are of these two types. Also, claims about medical effects are the task of the regulator and of medical personnel, not of a reference for growers. This paper gives chemistry for growers: the molecules, the sources of the molecules, and how to keep the molecules.

Quality of the information

Evidence and limitations

Three types of information

We want each paper to be correct. Thus we examine each paper for information that is not solid. This information comes from the view of one grower, from a small number of sources, or from grower methods that have no controlled test. We identify this information, and we do not show it as solid.

Frequently there is no paper for the decision that you must make. Then we use the reports of other growers and the methods that work in the rooms that we know. This information can help you, but it is not the result of a laboratory test. Use the methods that work for your plants, for your room and for your meters. If a table does not agree with your crop, use the data from your crop and record the difference.

Solid
Tests of plants, specifications or many sources that agree show that the information is correct
  • The primary definitions and the units of measurement in the paper
  • Safety limits that have a citation to a regulation or a specification
Grower method
Many growers use this method in their rooms. Start with it, then change it for your room.
  • Target ranges for light, climate and feed in each stage. They are start values that you can change.
  • SOPs that work in many rooms, but you must adjust them for your genetics and meters
Weak
The view of one grower, a small number of sources, one test, or a method that works in one room
  • A number for yield or potency that you will always get, with no test at many sites
  • Controller setpoints from a different facility, with no new calibration

If you find an error, make a report. We will correct it. Make the report on GitHub, with the name of the paper and the information that is incorrect. If you have a source, include it: Make a report of an accuracy problem. The regulations, labels and licenses of your area always override each procedure in these papers. The label weak in a paper shows the points where the risk of an error is highest.

In short

Basic facts of the chemistry

The plant makes all the compounds that have a value in trichome heads. It makes them as acids (THCA and CBDA, not THC and CBD) on one pathway. In the middle of the pathway is one molecule: CBGA, the ‘mother cannabinoid’[3].

The genes control the ratio of the products (the chemotype). They also control most of the terpene profile[7]. The cultivation controls how much the plant makes. After harvest, the quantity of the compounds can only decrease.

The two groups decrease for different causes, and half of this paper is about this difference. Terpenes evaporate. When the temperature of a surface increases, the molecules go from the surface into the air at a higher rate. The light ‘monoterpenes’ evaporate at room temperature. Thus during fast drying with hot air, the room has a strong aroma, but the quantity of terpenes in the product decreases[10].

Cannabinoids oxidize. Oxygen changes the cannabinoids slowly. No enzyme is necessary, and the change cannot occur in the opposite direction. The oxidation of THC makes CBN. Of all the causes, light makes the degradation of THC the fastest[17].

Warm air decreases the flavor. Light, oxygen and a long storage time decrease the potency.

The primary point of this paper

The plant makes the potency and the flavor one time only, in the same gland, as acids that change easily and oils that evaporate easily. The task of the grower has three parts. Select genetics that can make the compounds. Keep the plant in good condition. It can then fill the trichomes. From the time of harvest, keep the product cool, in darkness and sealed, and touch it carefully.

Photo of transparent stalked trichomes on a cannabis bract, at a high magnification
Example. Capitate-stalked trichomes at a high magnification. Each head has a storage cavity with a wall. The cavity contains the resin, which has cannabinoid acids and terpenes.Grok Imagine
The production site

Cells of the trichome that make resin

Cannabis has three types of glandular trichome. The bulbous trichome is very small. The sessile trichome is flat on the surface. The capitate-stalked trichome has a resin head on a stalk, and it is the type that gives the most value. A microscope shows that the heads of stalked trichomes have 12 to 16 secretory disc cells at the bottom. The heads of sessile trichomes have eight.

The stalked trichome is the type that agrees with a high cannabinoid content[2]. A stalked trichome starts from a trichome that looks the same as a sessile trichome, and it changes as the maturity of the flower increases. The ‘frost’ on the flower increases during flowering. The cause is not only that the plant makes more trichomes. The trichomes also change from one type to a different type[2].

In a capitate-stalked trichome: where the plant makes and keeps resinThis diagram is not to scale. The plant makes and keeps almost all the compounds that have a value in this one structure.leaf / bract surface (epidermis)Cuticle: a thin layer of waxIt is the wall of the cavity.It breaks if you are not careful.Storage cavitycannabinoid acids + terpenescollect here as resinSecretory disc cells12 to 16 in a stalked trichome.They make the resin.Stalklifts the head above theleaf surface. It breaks easily.Sessile trichome8 disc cells, flat on the surfaceless resin for each headbulbous trichome(very small)The plant makes the resin one time and keeps it here. It does not absorb the resin again. After this diagram, the task is to keep the resin.
Figure 1. A cross-section of the capitate-stalked trichome. The disc cells at the bottom of the head make the resin. The storage cavity above the disc cells keeps the resin, and a cuticle is the wall of the cavity. Heads of stalked trichomes have 12 to 16 disc cells and a profile with a high content of cannabinoids and monoterpenes. Heads of sessile trichomes have eight disc cells[2].

The two parts of the trichome have different tasks. The disc cells make the resin. Isolated trichomes show a high expression of the genes for the biosynthesis of cannabinoids and terpenes[2]. When the resin is complete, it goes into the storage cavity.

The only wall of the cavity is a thin layer of wax, the cuticle. The plant does not absorb the resin again. After the plant makes the resin, it stays in the cavity. The cavity gives protection to the resin, but it breaks easily, and it is on the surface of the plant.

The anatomy of the trichome causes three results for the grower:

  • The potency is on the surface. The quantity of resin increases with the surface area of the bracts and sugar leaves, not with the mass of the bud. One result is that flower with a high density of bracts and good light has a higher potency in a lab test than low-density flower.
  • If you are not careful when you touch the flower, you remove resin. The wall of the cavity is a film of wax. Movement of the flower in equipment, pressure on the flower, many touches and trimming that is not careful break the heads. As a result, the resin stays on gloves and equipment and not in the jar.
  • The solventless methods use this anatomy. Ice-water hash and dry sift are methods that remove the heads of trichomes from the flower when the heads are cold. Cold heads break off the stalk and stay in good condition. Thus the methods collect the storage cavities without the other parts of the plant.
Information that only a loupe gives

A loupe tells you the density of the heads, the size of the heads, and the condition of the heads after you touch them. A loupe gives you this information faster than a lab test. If the heads in the product from your trimming room look rough at 60×, the potency is in the equipment and not in the bag.

The pathway

Cannabinoid and terpene biosynthesis

Know the pathway, because the chemotypes, CBG flower, THCV and half of the COA are results of the pathway. The plant starts with hexanoyl-CoA, a starter unit that has six carbons and is from the metabolism of fatty acids. The plant adds three malonyl-CoA units to it and makes olivetolic acid, the aromatic core. A polyketide synthase does this together with olivetolic acid cyclase (OAC)[3].

Then the two parts of the molecule connect. An enzyme in a membrane, a prenyltransferase, attaches a terpene unit with ten carbons to olivetolic acid. This terpene unit is geranyl diphosphate (GPP). A test in 1998 first showed the enzyme as GOT, geranylpyrophosphate:olivetolate geranyltransferase.

The product is cannabigerolic acid (CBGA). The enzyme accepts olivetolic acid, but it does not accept olivetol, which is olivetolic acid without the carboxyl group. Thus each product of the pathway is an acid[4].

Biosynthesis: two starter units, one middle compound, three branchesThe enzymes are on the arrows. The plant makes all the primary cannabinoids from CBGA. Thus CBGA is the mother cannabinoid.Hexanoyl-CoAC6 starter unit (from fatty acids)+3 × malonyl-CoAunits for a longer carbon chainGeranyl diphosphate (GPP)the C10 terpene unitpolyketide synthase + OACOlivetolic acidthe aromatic coreGOT prenyltransferase connects themCBGA: cannabigerolic acidthe mother cannabinoid: each branch starts hereThe propyl seriesa shorter starter unit givesdivarinic acid → CBGVA →THCVA / CBDVA, with the sameenzymes and a shorter side chain.THCA synthaseCBDA synthaseCBCA synthaseTHCAacid of THCCBDAacid of CBDCBCAacid of CBCheat → −CO2 (decarboxylation)Δ9-THCCBDCBCNot on the diagram: CBN. No synthase makes CBN. CBN is oxidized THC, a degradation product and not a product of biosynthesis.Most other cannabinoids are compounds that heat, light or oxidation make from these primary cannabinoids. They are not branches of the pathway.
Figure 2. The diagram of the pathway. A starter unit from fatty acids and a terpene unit connect to make CBGA. Three oxidocyclase enzymes (THCA synthase, CBDA synthase and CBCA synthase) each change CBGA to a different acid[3][4]. The diagram does not show CBN or neutral THC, because no branch makes them.

CBGA is in the middle of the pathway: it is the mother cannabinoid. Three synthases use CBGA at the same time. THCA synthase changes it to THCA, CBDA synthase changes it to CBDA, and CBCA synthase changes it to CBCA[3]. The chemotype locus controls the enzymes that operate correctly in a plant. A subsequent section gives more information about the locus.

The pathway has two more facts. First, the propyl series. When the pathway starts from a shorter starter unit, the same enzymes make divarinic acid, then CBGVA, then THCVA and CBDVA. These compounds are the ‘varin’ cannabinoids, which have a side chain with three carbons, for example THCV[3][1].

Second, the plant makes almost no CBN and a very small quantity of neutral THC. The two compounds are degradation products of the compounds that the enzymes made. The enzymes do not make them[3].

The enzyme diagram: information for the grower

The diagram gives the cause of three results. The first result is CBG flower. Flower with a high content of CBG is from a plant. In this plant, the synthases after CBGA do not operate correctly, thus the quantity of CBGA increases.

The second result is the chemotype. The chemotype is the set of synthase alleles that the plant gets from its parents. Thus no change in the environment can change THC to CBD. The third result is CBN on a COA. CBN is a record of the storage, and it is not a genetic trait. Breeding cannot increase or decrease CBN, because no synthase makes CBN.

Acids and neutral compounds

Decarboxylation: THCA and THC

Many persons do not know this fact: the plant does not make THC in an important quantity. It makes THCA, which is the same molecule with a carboxyl group (–COOH). THCA does not cause intoxication. Flower that you did not heat contains acid that is not active. Heat removes the carboxyl group as CO₂ gas and makes the molecule active. This reaction is decarboxylation[5].

Decarboxylation: heat removes CO2, and THCA becomes THCTHCA−COOHthe acid that the plant makesdoes not cause intoxicationtoo much heat or timebreaks the THC that it makesattached carboxyl group →heat + time− CO2CO2gas: 12.3%of the massΔ9-THCneutral, and causes intoxication1.000 g THCA → 0.877 g THCmore heat or time: it oxidizesand changes to CBNsame structure, no −COOHThe total on a COAtotal THC = THC + 0.877 × THCA. The number 0.877 is the fraction of the mass of a THCA moleculethat stays after it releases CO2 (314.5 ÷ 358.5). The number is the same for CBDA → CBD.
Figure 3. The change from THCA to THC. Heat removes the –COOH from THCA. THCA releases CO₂ as a gas (12.3% of the mass of the molecule), and Δ9-THC stays. The number 0.877 on each COA is only the fraction of the mass that stays.

When a person burns the flower or applies heat to it in a vaporizer, decarboxylation is complete in less than one second. In all other methods (ovens, extracts and the production of edibles), the rate of the reaction controls the result, and tests measured the rate correctly. The data of Wang show that the decarboxylation of cannabis extract between 80 °C (176 °F) and 145 °C (293 °F) is first-order. The rate constants for THCA are 0.18, 0.66 and 1.83 × 10⁻³ s⁻¹ at 80 °C (176 °F), 95 °C (203 °F) and 110 °C (230 °F)[5]. Thus at 110 °C (230 °F), half of the THCA that stays changes to THC in each period of approximately six minutes.

Change of THCA to THC at 110 °C (first-order)Calculated from the measured first-order rate constant k = 1.83 × 10⁻³ s⁻¹ at 110 °C. Half-life ≈ 6.3 min. X-axis in minutes.0255075100036912151821242730% THCA remaining
Figure 4. In a first-order reaction, the conversion is fast at the start and slow at the end. The time for the last small percentage of acid is the same as the time for the first 50%. The curve uses the rate constant in the data of Wang[5].

The acids do not change at the same rate. THCA changes approximately two times as fast as CBDA or CBGA at the same temperature. The activation energy of THCA is lower (88 kJ/mol compared with 112 kJ/mol and 109 kJ/mol)[5]. If a person uses the same schedule of heat for CBD material as for THC, the decarboxylation of the CBD material is not complete.

Half-life of each acid at 110 °CHalf-life = ln 2 ÷ k, from the first-order rate constants measured at 110 °C. THCA is the fastest.04812166.3 minTHCA11.6 minCBGA13.9 minCBDA
Figure 5. The three acids change at different rates in the same oven. The time for CBDA and CBGA is approximately two times the time for THCA at the same temperature. The times are from the rate constants in the data of Wang[5].

Decarboxylation has two risks. If the time of heat is too short, acid that is not active stays. If the temperature is too high or the time is too long, the THC that the reaction made oxidizes more and changes to CBN. Also, the monoterpenes evaporate very fast at the temperature of decarboxylation, and they go from the material into the air[10].

One result of the tests of the rate is important. In a vacuum, THCA changed to THC and the test found no CBN. When you remove the oxygen from the reaction, the degradation of the THC almost stops[5].

Decarboxylation continues at room temperature

At room temperature, decarboxylation continues at a very low rate. During some months of storage, the acids in the flower change slowly to neutral compounds. Thus the COA of a jar in long storage and the COA at harvest can show different values. The difference occurs before the potency decreases. When the ratio of THCA to THC changes but the total THC stays the same, the cause is decarboxylation. It is not degradation.

The primary cannabinoids

Primary cannabinoids

Six cannabinoids are the most important in flower products. For each cannabinoid, the entry below gives the definition (It is), the source, and the incorrect claims about it (It is not). This paper gives effects carefully. An effect that is a report comes from reports of persons who use the compound, or from first tests. It is not a medical effect that sufficient tests show.

primary compound
Δ9-THC / THCA

It is: the primary cannabinoid that causes intoxication. In the plant, it is almost all THCA. The price of THC-dominant flower is for the quantity of THC.
It is not: an indicator of quality. Two flowers with 20% total THC can be very different in aroma, time since harvest and condition of the resin. The potency is only one item of the COA, and it does not show all the quality of the flower.

second primary compound
CBD / CBDA

It is: a primary cannabinoid that does not cause intoxication. It is the dominant cannabinoid in plants of chemotype III, and it is the primary cannabinoid in hemp production. It is one of the cannabinoids with the most medical investigations.
It is not: a license for claims. A claim about the diseases for which CBD has an effect is the task of medical personnel. The information that a grower gives stops at the measured percentage.

neutral compound of the mother acid
CBG / CBGA

It is: the neutral compound of the mother acid. Most flower has much less than 1% CBG, because the plant uses CBGA to make all the other cannabinoids. Cultivars of chemotype IV have a high quantity of CBGA, because their synthases after CBGA do not operate correctly[8].
It is not: ‘the new THC’. It does not cause intoxication. Suppliers give most claims about it, and the data are not sufficient for them.

sign of storage time
CBN

It is: the oxidation product of THC. Heat, oxygen and time make CBN, and no enzyme makes it. CBN is a very good sign of degradation, thus persons use the ratio of CBN to THC to get an estimate of the storage time[6].
It is not: a product that causes sedation, with an effect that tests show. The claim that CBN is a ‘sedating cannabinoid’ is frequent, but the data for it are weak. On a COA, read CBN first as a sign of the storage time.

small branch
CBC / CBCA

It is: the third branch from CBGA, through CBCA synthase. Persons found CBC in the 1960s, and in the data it is one of the primary cannabinoids[1]. It does not cause intoxication. The quantity is usually a fraction of one percent.
It is not: a cannabinoid that most growers will select for. Labs frequently give no result for CBC.

related to THC
THCV / THCVA

It is: a compound related to THC that has a short ‘propyl’ side chain, from the propyl series. Persons first found THCV in 1971. Some cultivars contain a much higher quantity[1].
It is not: a product for appetite or energy with an effect that tests show. Investigations of the effects in reports are in progress. The supply is small, and at this time THCV is mostly a task of breeders.

The other 119

Most of the other cannabinoids in the lists occur in trace quantities only. They are related compounds, isomers, or compounds that heat, light or the lab test makes. They are correct chemistry, but they have almost no effect on the price of flower[1]. A data sheet for a product can give a cannabinoid that is not one of the primary cannabinoids. We recommend that you make sure that the COA gives the quantity of that cannabinoid.

Genetics first

Chemotypes I–V and ratios from the parents

One locus (a position on the DNA) controls the cannabinoid ratio. The locus controls the ratio from the seed, and you cannot change the ratio after that. When you make a cross of a THC-dominant plant and a CBD-dominant plant and examine the offspring, the cannabinoid ratio is a Mendelian trait. There are two alleles, and you can calculate the ratios in the offspring.

The investigations of genetics show that one locus, B, controls the ratio. The locus has two codominant alleles: BT (a THCA synthase that operates correctly) and BD (a CBDA synthase that operates correctly). A plant with two copies of BT is THC-dominant (chemotype I). A plant with two copies of BD is CBD-dominant (chemotype III). A plant with one copy of each is chemotype II, which has a mixed ratio of approximately 1:1. In F₂ crosses, the chemotypes occur in the ratio 1:2:1, which agrees with the Mendelian ratio[7].

Chemotypes I–V: one locus controls the ratio, and breeding controls the other traitsThe bar heights show the ratio of the compounds in each type. They do not show the potency.Type IType IIType IIIType IVType VTHCCBDTHCCBDTHCCBDCBGnoneTHC-dominantBalanced (approximately 1:1)CBD-dominantCBG-dominantNo cannabinoidsBT / BTBT / BDBD / BDB0 (no enzyme)o / oalmost all currentflower productsthe two synthases operate,cultivars with a balanced ratiohemp and CBDcultivarssynthases after CBGA do notoperate, thus CBGA increasesa recessive allele stopsthe pathway. Only for breeding.THC / THCACBD / CBDACBG / CBGAThe ratio is a Mendelian trait and is in the genes from germination. Many genes and the environment control the total quantity. The locus controls the ratio, not the quantity.
Figure 6. The five chemotypes. Types I to III are the result of the B locus, and thus of the synthase alleles of the plant[7]. Type IV has a high quantity of CBGA, because the conversion after CBGA does not operate correctly. Type V has no cannabinoids. A recessive allele (o/o) stops the pathway. In crosses, this allele also gives the ratio 1:2:1[8].

The two other chemotypes complete the diagram. Type IV plants have synthases after CBGA that do not operate. Thus the quantity of the mother acid CBGA increases. The result is CBG flower.

Type V plants make no cannabinoids. Crosses with usual plants showed that one recessive allele (o) stops the pathway fully. The ratio is again 1:2:1[8]. Chemotype V is only a plant for fiber breeding and for investigations. It shows that genetics controls each type of the ratio.

An important limit: the locus controls the ratio, but it does not control the quantity. Many genes and the environment control the total quantity of cannabinoid that a plant makes. The environment includes the condition of the canopy, the light and the maturity at harvest. Thus the breeding and the selection of seed control the ratio. The cultivation controls the total quantity[7].

Find the chemotype before you give bench space to a cultivar

A lab test of a leaf from a plant before the flowering stage gives the chemotype. You can find that a ‘CBD line’ is chemotype II before the room is in the flowering stage. A plant of chemotype II will have a high THC content. If the product is for medical use, the ratios must have a certificate. Make sure of the chemotype before you give bench space to a cultivar.

Dark, cool drying room with cannabis plants that hang on lines
Example. Dry the flower slowly in a cold, dark room. In a warm room, the monoterpenes evaporate from the flower first.Grok Imagine
Terpene groups

Terpene groups and volatility

Each terpene contains isoprene units, and each unit has five carbons. Monoterpenes have two units (C10): myrcene, limonene, pinene, terpinolene and linalool. Sesquiterpenes have three units (C15): caryophyllene and humulene[9]. The two types have a different number of units.

Cannabis makes the two types in the same trichomes as the cannabinoids. Reports show approximately 61 monoterpenes and 51 sesquiterpenes in the species[1]. A group of terpene synthase genes controls the terpenes that a cultivar makes in a high quantity[9].

The primary difference of the groups for the grower is the volatility. Volatility is how easily a compound goes from a material into the air. A molecule goes into the air when it has sufficient energy to go from the surface of the liquid. Monoterpenes have a high volatility. Sesquiterpenes have a volatility approximately 100 times lower. Cannabinoids almost do not evaporate.

The measured vapor pressures at 20 °C (68 °F) show this. The vapor pressures of monoterpenes are 1 to 4 Torr (α-pinene 3.57, β-pinene 2.18, myrcene 1.69 and limonene 1.13). The vapor pressures of sesquiterpenes are two orders of magnitude lower (β-caryophyllene 0.021 and α-humulene 0.010). The vapor pressures of cannabinoids are very much lower: CBD 6.3 × 10⁻⁶ Torr and THC 5.2 × 10⁻⁷ Torr[10].

The volatility scale: vapor pressure at 20 °CLog scale. For each step down, the volatility is 10× lower. Values in Torr at 20 °C.10110⁻¹10⁻²10⁻³10⁻⁴10⁻⁵10⁻⁶10⁻⁷α-pinene · 3.57β-pinene · 2.18myrcene · 1.69limonene · 1.13β-caryophyllene · 0.021α-humulene · 0.010CBD · 6.3 × 10⁻⁶Δ9-THC · 5.2 × 10⁻⁷Monoterpenesevaporate at room temperature.Hot, fast drying removes them first.Sesquiterpeneshave a volatility approximately 100× lower.They stay in the material during drying.Cannabinoidshave a volatility approximatelyone million times lower than monoterpenes.Potency oxidizes and does not evaporate.Incorrect claimCharts that show ‘THC boils at 155–157 °C’ are incorrect. The correct boiling point is more than 400 °C.Vapor pressure controls evaporation at temperatures less than the boiling point. Thus the flavor decreases long before the potency.
Figure 7. The values are in a range of seven orders of magnitude on one scale. Monoterpenes evaporate at room temperature. Sesquiterpenes have a volatility approximately 100× lower. Cannabinoids almost do not evaporate. The test measured the values at 20 °C (68 °F)[10]. Charts that show ‘THC boils at 157 °C (315 °F)’ are incorrect. The correct boiling point is more than 400 °C (752 °F). The test calculated this value from the data[10].

This chart gives information about the drying room. A test measured the volatile oil of the same buds when they were new and after drying in air and storage. The monoterpene proportion of the oil decreased from approximately 92% to 62% in three months, and the sesquiterpene proportion increased[11][1].

The part of the aroma from the monoterpenes evaporates first, and the profile changes to a pepper aroma and a wood aroma. The drying changed the proportions of the oil, but it did not change the list of compounds in the oil[11]. No new compound occurs, and the light fraction decreases. Cold, slow drying in darkness is a method to control the vapor pressure.

A weak aroma with a good THC value shows that the terpenes decreased

The potency stays when the conditions are not good, but the aroma does not. A sample can keep its THC value after some days in hot conditions and one month on a shelf, but its monoterpenes evaporate. When flower has a weak aroma but a good lab result, the cause is the volatility scale in the chart above.

The eight primary terpenes

Primary terpenes of flower products

Flower products have a small number of terpene profiles. A test of many thousand retail samples in the US found three primary groups of products. The first group has high caryophyllene and limonene. The second group has high myrcene and pinene. The third group has high terpinolene and myrcene[13]. The test also found that the labels indica, sativa and hybrid do not agree fully with the chemistry[13].

This section gives eight terpenes that you must know. The data for aroma are facts. This paper marks the claims about effects as claims without data.

most frequent terpene
Myrcene

Monoterpene. Aroma of soil, musk and mango. Flower products most frequently contain myrcene in a high quantity. Myrcene is a primary component of two of the three groups of products[13]. The claim that myrcene is a ‘couch-lock terpene’ has no data. The data show the aroma and the high quantity, not sedation.

citrus
Limonene

Monoterpene. Aroma of citrus peel. Limonene occurs with caryophyllene in one primary group of products[13]. Limonene evaporates easily: the vapor pressure is 1.13 Torr at 20 °C (68 °F)[10]. The quantity of limonene shows the storage time of the product, and limonene also gives flavor.

first to evaporate
α- / β-Pinene

Monoterpenes. Aroma of pine and resin. Of the primary terpenes, pinene evaporates the most easily (α-pinene 3.57 Torr[10]), thus pinene is the first terpene to evaporate in drying with warm air. Investigations of the claims about memory and alertness are in progress. At this time, think of pinene as an aroma only.

different from other terpenes
Terpinolene

Monoterpene. A mixed aroma: floral aroma, pine aroma and a small quantity of gasoline aroma. Terpinolene is not frequently the dominant terpene, but when it is, terpinolene gives the aroma of the cultivar. In one of the three groups of products, the terpinolene content is high[13].

special terpene
β-Caryophyllene

Sesquiterpene with an aroma of pepper and clove. Caryophyllene is different from all other terpenes. It is an agonist of the CB2 receptor (Ki = 155 nM), and it does not attach to the CB1 receptor. It is a ‘dietary cannabinoid’ that is also in black pepper[12]. The CB2 receptor does not cause intoxication, thus this effect is pharmacology and not potency. The volatility is low, and caryophyllene stays in the material during drying[10].

floral aroma
Linalool

Monoterpene alcohol. Aroma of lavender. The quantity in cannabis is almost always small, but the aroma is strong when linalool occurs. The data for the claim about relaxation are mostly from investigations of lavender oil and not from tests on cannabis. Investigations of the claim are in progress, and the data are not sufficient.

stays in the material
α-Humulene

Sesquiterpene. Aroma of hops (humulene is the compound with the typical aroma of hops), wood aroma and bitterness. It frequently occurs with caryophyllene. Of the primary terpenes that the test measured, it has the lowest volatility (0.010 Torr[10]).

secondary terpene
Ocimene

Monoterpene. Sweet aroma, green aroma and herb aroma. Ocimene frequently occurs as a secondary terpene. In some cultivars, the quantity is high. It evaporates easily in heat, the same as the other monoterpenes.

Caryophyllene and the receptor data

Suppliers give receptor claims for all terpenes. Caryophyllene is the only terpene for which the data show the receptor effect, and other tests found the same result[12]. A careful test of the other primary terpenes found no effect on the CB1 receptor or the CB2 receptor. The concentrations in the test can occur when a person uses the product[16]. Thus there is one correct example and many examples without data. The entourage effect has the same structure.

Data and claims

Entourage effect: data and claims

The claim is that a mixture of the compounds of cannabis has a stronger effect than one compound only. In this claim, terpenes and the small cannabinoids change the effect of THC. The most important paper about the claim is the paper of Russo from 2011. This paper gives the hypothesis of a synergy of cannabinoids and terpenoids for a range of diseases[14]. The paper is about a hypothesis. The paper gives a condition: a synergy, if tests show it, will make new products possible[14].

The table below gives the data. The data show three facts. Caryophyllene is a CB2 agonist[12]. Cannabis makes many hundred compounds that occur together[1]. In pharmacology, there are many examples of effects of mixtures.

One test gives the opposite result. It used the five terpenes that occur most frequently, with THC and without THC, on human CB1 and CB2 receptors. The test showed no receptor effect and no change of the signal of THC[16].

Other papers do not agree with the claim. These papers tell you that the term started as a ‘hypothetical afterthought’ in 1998. They tell you that suppliers at this time use the term in claims that show far more than the data show. They also tell you that persons do not frequently give information about bad effects of mixtures[15].

The data about the entourage effect, in a correct table.
ConditionClaimData at this time
Shownβ-caryophyllene is an agonist of the CB2 receptor (Ki 155 nM), and it has no effect on the CB1 receptorOther tests found the same receptor effect[12]
ShownCannabis contains many hundred compounds that occur togetherAccepted chemistry[1]
Not shownThe most frequent terpenes have an effect at the CB1 receptor or the CB2 receptor, or they change the effect of THC thereTests on the receptors found no effect[16]
HypothesisThe effects of flower with all its compounds are very different from the effects of isolate THCIt is possible, but no test shows it for products[14][15]
Supplier claim‘This terpene profile causes this effect’No test with controls shows a connection of a profile to an effect[15]

The data show only these facts. It is possible that mixtures have an effect. One mechanism is correct. The claims in the lists of suppliers that give an effect for each profile have no data. Tests of terpene mechanisms at the CB receptors did not find them.

Terpenes continue to have value. They give the flavor of the product, they are a record of the storage time, and they show the cultivar of the product. This value is sufficient without pharmacology from other sources.

Correct claims about chemistry

Give the data that you measured. These data are the cannabinoid ratio, the total terpenes, the five terpenes with the highest weight, and the dates of harvest and test. Use aroma terms to give the aroma. Do not give information about effects. Only persons with a license can do this. For medical use, compliance makes this necessary.

Amber jars of cannabis flower in a dark cabinet
Example. Storage: keep the flower cool, in darkness and sealed, and write the date on the jar. These steps prevent the damage that light and oxygen cause.Grok Imagine
Degradation rates

Cannabinoid and terpene degradation

From the time of harvest, two changes decrease the quantity of the compounds at the same time, and they have different causes. Terpenes evaporate. They evaporate the fastest when the temperature is high, and monoterpenes evaporate first (previous sections).

Cannabinoids oxidize. The end product of the oxidation of THC is CBN. The causes are oxygen, heat, light and time. Each of the two changes occurs in one direction only. Each decision about storage controls the rate of these two changes.

One direction only: THCA → THC → CBNTHCAnew trichome materialΔ9-THCthe active stageCBNthe oxidation product of THC‘decarb’heat · timeoxidationslowheatoxygentimelightdecreases THC by mechanismsthat do not make CBNIn darkness, oxygen in the air continues to oxidize THC.Oxidation by air is the usual cause of CBN.Storage at room temperature in darkness (20–22 °C)THC is lower by 16.6% (year 1), 26.8% (year 2), 34.5% (year 3), 41.4% (year 4)CBN increases when THC decreases. The CBN:THC ratio changes at a known rate, thus it gives an estimate of the storage time.The temperature controls the rate of each change in this paper. Cool storage decreases all the rates.No enzyme makes CBN. If CBN increases on your COAs, the cause is the storage time of the sample and not its genetics.
Figure 8. The changes occur in one direction only. Decarboxylation changes THCA to THC, which is active. Oxidation changes THC to CBN. Light is different from the other causes. Light decreases the THC faster than the other causes, but through mechanisms that do not make CBN[17]. The values for storage are from the four-year test at room temperature[6].

Flower in storage at 20 to 22 °C (68 to 72 °F) in darkness had a THC content that was, on average, 16.6% lower after the first year. After year two, the THC content was 26.8% lower. After year three, it was 34.5% lower. After year four, it was 41.4% lower. The ratio of CBN to THC increased at a rate that you can calculate. Thus persons use the ratio to get an estimate of the storage time of a sample[6].

THC remaining: room-temperature storage in darknessPlant material at 20–22 °C in darkness. Average values (±6–8%) from the four-year storage test.0285582110100%Harvest83%Year 173%Year 266%Year 359%Year 4
Figure 9. In good conditions (darkness and room temperature), the potency decreases by approximately two-fifths in four years. Heat, light and the air in the container each make the potency decrease faster[6].

Tests of storage for two years give the sequence of the causes. Of all causes, light decreased the cannabinoids the most, and the light was not necessarily bright sunlight. Compared with light, temperature up to 20 °C (68 °F) had no important effect. Oxidation by air also decreased the cannabinoids by an important quantity[17].

The same tests give more information about the mechanisms (Figure 8). When light decreases the THC, the THC does not become CBN. When oxidation by air in darkness decreases the THC, the THC does become CBN. Thus a sample with a high CBN content was in warm storage with air, and it was not necessarily in bright light[17].

Material in good storage was ‘reasonably stable’ for one to two years in darkness at room temperature[17].

Terpenes also decrease in storage, and not only by evaporation. They also decrease by oxidation. Oxidation changes the aroma of the terpenes and not their quantity. Oxidized monoterpenes have a stale aroma: the pine aroma changes to a solvent aroma. The change in the proportions in dried buds in storage (the monoterpene proportion from 92% to 62%) is the result of the two decreases together[11].

LightCause number 1 (the largest effect). Use containers that do not transmit light. Keep rooms in darkness. Do not use jars for display[17].
TemperatureCool storage is always better than warm storage. The temperature controls the rate of each change in this paper.
OxygenThe cause of the change to CBN. Use full, sealed containers with a small volume of air[17].
Surface areaBuds that stay as buds keep the protection of the cuticle. Flower in small pieces has a larger surface area, and the compounds decrease faster.
TimeYou cannot stop time. Supply the product when it is new, and write a date on each lot[6].
Do not use a clear jar to display flower

Do not keep flower in a clear jar that has lights above it. A clear jar lets light go in, and light is the cause with the largest effect. The lights also give heat, and new air goes into the jar each time you open it. As a result, the flower changes to CBN and the aroma becomes weak. Keep the stock for display in a different area from your other stock.

Levers from large to small effect

Cultivation levers and their limits

The list gives the levers in the sequence of their effect on the numbers. It gives the condition of the data for each lever. Many claims of suppliers, and many claims of growers without data, are about these levers.

  1. Genetics has the largest effect. The effect of each other lever is much smaller. The chemotype is a Mendelian trait[7]. The terpene synthase genes of the cultivar control the terpene profile[9]. The chemistry of flower products is in groups, and each group agrees with a group of cultivars[13]. If the plant cannot make a compound, no setting of the environment will cause the plant to make it.
  2. Time of harvest. When the ripeness of the flowers increases, the maturity of the trichomes increases and the heads change. The profiles also change, and tests can measure the change[2]. If you harvest on a set date and not on the condition of the trichomes, you do not get all the compounds. The cultivation had a cost for these compounds.
  3. The condition of the plant and the light. A canopy that is full, in good condition and has good light has more surface area of trichomes. The correct method to get ‘more terpenes’ is more glands. Special inputs do not do this.
  4. Changes of the environment. The effect is small, the data do not agree, and the effect is different for different cultivars. Read the information about UV below before you accept the cost of equipment for this lever.
  5. After harvest, the compounds cannot increase, but they can decrease by a large quantity. Drying, curing and storage can only keep the compounds (previous section). They control rates and do not make compounds.

The UV claim is important, because suppliers of equipment use it. The claim is that UV stress causes the plant to make more THC as a protection. The claim uses the data of small tests from many years before. A correct test used current THC-dominant cultivars in a grow room and a range of UV-B doses. The test showed that the concentration of cannabinoids did not increase and the yield did not increase. It also showed that the damage to photosynthesis increased when the dose increased[18].

The test is one careful test on two cultivars. It is not the last result for each genotype and spectrum. But at this time the supplier of UV equipment must show test data for the claim.

The data for environment claims in short

Tests with controls give the same result each time. Genetics and the condition of the plant have the largest effect. ‘Stress hacks’ in the environment give small changes in chemistry. The changes are different in each test and different for each cultivar, and they decrease the yield. We recommend that each input with the claim of +30% terpenes has a COA pair and the name of a cultivar. If it does not, the claim has no data.

Laboratory bench with HPLC vials and a certificate of analysis
Example. The COA is the record of your procedures. It gives the acids and the neutral cannabinoids, and the terpene panel. The ratios show the history of the storage.Grok Imagine
The record

Cannabinoids and terpenes on a COA

A COA is a table with the results of all the chemistry in this paper. The cannabinoid section of the COA gives a result for each acid and a result for each neutral compound. New flower in good storage has almost all the THC as THCA and a small quantity as THC. Use the number for decarboxylation from Figure 3 to get the total:

total THCTHC + 0.877 × THCA. The number 0.877 is the fraction of the mass that stays after the molecule releases CO₂.
total CBDCBD + 0.877 × CBDA. The number and the cause are the same.
Source of the number 0.877The molar mass of the neutral compound (314.5) divided by the molar mass of the acid (358.5). The number is only chemistry and not biology.
Dry weightLabs usually correct the results for moisture. Before you compare labs, find if each lab gives the results for dry weight.

When you read more than the primary number on the COA, the COA is a record of the sample:

  • High THCA, low THC and almost no CBN: the material is new, and the storage was cool. You want this result.
  • The neutral fraction increases slowly: the cause is storage time or heat. Decarboxylation occurred in storage (Section 5).
  • CBN occurs and increases: CBN is the sign of the storage time. The storage was warm, had air, or was only for a long time[6].
  • The terpene total is low, and the quantity of sesquiterpenes is high for the cultivar. The monoterpenes evaporated. The cause is hot drying or a long time on a shelf[11].
  • Chemotype that does not agree: a ‘CBD cultivar’ with a large THC content has genetics of chemotype II. The B locus causes this result[7].

A terpene panel typically gives a list of compounds in percent by weight. A small number of compounds make most of the total. The shape of the profile shows the cultivar[13], and the condition of the profile is the record of your procedures. The paper about lab testing in this group of papers gives information about sampling, uncertainty and the differences in the results of different labs.

Use a COA pair

One COA gives the data of one sample. Two COAs of the same lot give the data about your storage: one COA at packaging and one COA some months after. The differences are that THCA changes to THC, CBN occurs, and monoterpenes evaporate. These differences are the chemistry of degradation in this paper, measured on your product.

Where the compounds decrease

Frequent causes of low cannabinoid and terpene content

Each cause in this section is a result of the chemistry in the previous sections. The sign in the COA shows the cause after the cause occurred. The correction makes sure that the cause does not occur again.

time of harvest
Harvest on a set date

The maturity of the trichome heads is too low, or it is after the peak. The profile of the cultivar does not become full[2].
Sign in the COA: the totals of potency and terpenes are lower than the known maximum for the cultivar.
Correction: examine the trichomes with a loupe. Harvest on the condition of the plant, not on a set date.

drying
Hot, fast drying

Monoterpenes evaporate from warm surfaces. The vapor pressure causes this[10][11].
Sign in the COA: the aroma is weak, the terpene total in the panel is low, and the proportion of sesquiterpenes is high.
Correction: dry the flower with cool air, slowly, and in darkness. A room that is cold to a person is approximately correct.

storage
Light on product in storage

In the papers about storage, light is the cause that decreases the cannabinoids the most[17].
Sign in the COA: the THC content decreases, but the CBN content does not increase by the same quantity.
Correction: use packaging that does not transmit light, keep the product in rooms in darkness, and do not keep product for display in windows.

storage
Heat, oxygen and months

The usual cause of CBN is oxidation by air in storage[17][6].
Sign in the COA: the COA shows CBN, and the CBN content increases. The flavor is bad.
Correction: keep the storage cool. Use full containers with a small volume of air. Supply the stock in the sequence of the dates.

movement
Touch that is not careful, and small pieces of flower

Each movement of the flower in equipment breaks heads, because the wall of a head is a cuticle. Flower in small pieces has a larger surface area, thus evaporation and oxidation are faster.
Sign in the COA: the loose material that falls from the buds has a higher potency in a lab test than the buds. The aroma of the product decreases in some days.
Correction: use careful settings for trimming and do not move the product many times. Make the flower into small pieces only at the time that you use it.

cost
Cost of claims about stress

The claims for UV equipment and stress procedures use only data from many years before. The test with controls found that the cannabinoids did not increase and that the damage increased when the dose increased[18].
Sign in the COA: the cost increases, but the COAs do not change.
Correction: make sure that the supplier gives COA pairs for your cultivar. Do this before you accept the cost of equipment that gives light with no value in the product.

Tables for reference

Reference tables

The six cannabinoids that are important in flower products.
CompoundParent acidSourceIt isIt is not
Δ9-THCTHCATHCA synthase ← CBGAThe cannabinoid that causes intoxication. The price is for the quantity of THC.An indicator of quality
CBDCBDACBDA synthase ← CBGAA primary cannabinoid that does not cause intoxicationA license for medical claims
CBGCBGAThe middle of the pathwayThe neutral compound of the mother acid. The primary cannabinoid of chemotype IV.‘The new THC’
CBNNoneOxidized THC. No enzyme makes it.A sign of the storage time[6]A product of biosynthesis, or a cause of sedation that tests show
CBCCBCACBCA synthase ← CBGAThe small third branch. Trace quantities.A compound that most COAs give a result for
THCVTHCVAPropyl series (‘varin’)A compound related to THC with a short side chain. The quantity is different for different cultivars.A compound with an effect that the data show
The eight primary terpenes (and β-pinene). A cell without a value shows that the test of vapor pressure that this paper uses has no measured value.
TerpeneGroupAromaVapor pressure at 20 °C (Torr)Stays in the material during drying
α-PineneMonoterpenePine, resin3.57[10]Very low. It evaporates first.
β-PineneMonoterpenePine, herb aroma2.18[10]Low
MyrceneMonoterpeneSoil, mango1.69[10]Low
LimoneneMonoterpeneCitrus peel1.13[10]Low
TerpinoleneMonoterpeneFloral aroma, pine, gasoline aroma—Low (monoterpene)
OcimeneMonoterpeneSweet aroma, green aroma—Low (monoterpene)
LinaloolMonoterpene (alcohol)Lavender—Average
β-CaryophylleneSesquiterpenePepper, clove0.021[10]High. It also has the CB2 receptor effect[12]
α-HumuleneSesquiterpeneHops, wood aroma0.010[10]The highest of the primary terpenes
Six numbers that contain most of the information in this paper.
Important numberValueInformation
Mass number for decarboxylation0.877Total THC = THC + 0.877 × THCA on each COA
THCA half-life at 110 °C≈ 6.3 minThe half-life of CBDA and CBGA is approximately two times longer[5]
Monoterpene proportion, new product → product in storage≈ 92% → 62%Three months of drying and storage[11]
The THC content decreases in year one at 20–22 °C (68–72 °F)≈ 17%Storage in darkness. Light makes the potency decrease faster[6][17]
Caryophyllene CB2 Ki155 nMThe only connection of a terpene to a receptor that tests show[12]
Ratio of chemotypes in the offspring1:2:1One locus with codominant alleles[7]
The model

Control of cannabinoids and terpenes

From seed to certificate: the control of the chemistry1Geneticschemotype andterpene profile:in the seed→2Trichomestrichomes makeand keep thecompounds→3Harvestpeak quantity:harvest by thetrichomes→4Dry, curemonoterpenesevaporate first:dry cool, slowly→5Storageoxidation withtime: darkness,cool, sealed→6COAthe record ofeach decisionaboveProduction stops at harvest. Each stage after it controls the rates of evaporation and oxidation.
Figure 10. All of this paper in one row. Before harvest (on the left), you can make compounds. After harvest (on the right), you can only keep them.
The plant makes the compounds one time, then you slow the degradation

The plant makes the compounds one time. After that, the quantity can only decrease. The genetics set the profile. The trichomes make the compounds and keep them as acids that change easily and oils that evaporate easily. From the time of harvest, you control two rates: evaporation for the flavor and oxidation for the potency.

No product can add the compounds again. The complete procedure after harvest has five parts: cool storage, darkness, sealed containers, careful movement of the product, and a short storage time. The COA is the correct record of each decision above.

Read these papers after this paper: lab testing and COAs, harvest, dry, trim and cure, and hash and rosin pressing. The paper about lab testing and COAs tells you how labs measure these numbers, and how labs measure them incorrectly. The paper about harvest, dry, trim and cure tells you the procedure that decreases or keeps the terpenes. The paper about hash and rosin pressing tells you the result when you collect the trichome heads and use the compounds in a different product.

Related papers

References

  1. Radwan MM, Chandra S, Gul S, ElSohly MA (2021). Cannabinoids, phenolics, terpenes and alkaloids of cannabis. Molecules 26(9):2774. (125 cannabinoids and 120 terpenes among >500 reported constituents.) https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8125862/
  2. Livingston SJ, Quilichini TD, Booth JK, et al. (2020). Cannabis glandular trichomes alter morphology and metabolite content during flower maturation. The Plant Journal 101(1):37-56. https://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/tpj.14516
  3. Gülck T, Møller BL (2020). Phytocannabinoids: origins and biosynthesis. Trends in Plant Science 25(10):985-1004. https://www.cell.com/trends/plant-science/fulltext/S1360-1385(20)30187-4
  4. Fellermeier M, Zenk MH (1998). Prenylation of olivetolate by a hemp transferase yields cannabigerolic acid, the precursor of tetrahydrocannabinol. FEBS Letters 427(2):283-285. https://febs.onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1016/S0014-5793(98)00450-5
  5. Wang M, Wang Y-H, Avula B, et al. (2016). Decarboxylation study of acidic cannabinoids: a novel approach using ultra-high-performance supercritical fluid chromatography/photodiode array-mass spectrometry. Cannabis and Cannabinoid Research 1(1):262-271. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC5549281/
  6. Ross SA, ElSohly MA (1997). CBN and Δ9-THC concentration ratio as an indicator of the age of stored marijuana samples. Bulletin on Narcotics (UNODC) 49(1-2):139-147. https://www.unodc.org/unodc/en/data-and-analysis/bulletin/bulletin_1997-01-01_1_page008.html
  7. de Meijer EPM, Bagatta M, Carboni A, et al. (2003). The inheritance of chemical phenotype in Cannabis sativa L. Genetics 163(1):335-346. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC1462421/
  8. de Meijer EPM, Hammond KM, Sutton A (2009). The inheritance of chemical phenotype in Cannabis sativa L. (IV): cannabinoid-free plants. Euphytica 168:95-112. https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10681-009-9894-7
  9. Booth JK, Bohlmann J (2019). Terpenes in Cannabis sativa — from plant genome to humans. Plant Science 284:67-72. https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0168945219301190
  10. Eyal AM, Berneman Zeitouni D, Tal D, et al. (2023). Vapor pressure, vaping, and corrections to misconceptions related to medical cannabis' active pharmaceutical ingredients' physical properties and compositions. Cannabis and Cannabinoid Research 8(3):414-425. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC10249740/
  11. Ross SA, ElSohly MA (1996). The volatile oil composition of fresh and air-dried buds of Cannabis sativa. Journal of Natural Products 59(1):49-51. https://pubs.acs.org/doi/10.1021/np960004a
  12. Gertsch J, Leonti M, Raduner S, et al. (2008). Beta-caryophyllene is a dietary cannabinoid. PNAS 105(26):9099-9104. (Selective CB2 agonist, Ki = 155 ± 4 nM; no CB1 binding.) https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC2449371/
  13. Smith CJ, Vergara D, Keegan B, Jikomes N (2022). The phytochemical diversity of commercial cannabis in the United States. PLoS ONE 17(5):e0267498. https://journals.plos.org/plosone/article?id=10.1371/journal.pone.0267498
  14. Russo EB (2011). Taming THC: potential cannabis synergy and phytocannabinoid-terpenoid entourage effects. British Journal of Pharmacology 163(7):1344-1364. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC3165946/
  15. Cogan PS (2020). The ‘entourage effect’ or ‘hodge-podge hashish’: the questionable rebranding, marketing, and expectations of cannabis polypharmacy. Expert Review of Clinical Pharmacology 13(8):835-845. https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/abs/10.1080/17512433.2020.1721281
  16. Finlay DB, Sircombe KJ, Nimick M, Jones C, Glass M (2020). Terpenoids from cannabis do not mediate an entourage effect by acting at cannabinoid receptors. Frontiers in Pharmacology 11:359. https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/pharmacology/articles/10.3389/fphar.2020.00359/full
  17. Fairbairn JW, Liebmann JA, Rowan MG (1976). The stability of cannabis and its preparations on storage. Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology 28(1):1-7. https://academic.oup.com/jpp/article-abstract/28/1/1/6196321
  18. Rodriguez-Morrison V, Llewellyn D, Zheng Y (2021). Cannabis inflorescence yield and cannabinoid concentration are not increased with exposure to short-wavelength ultraviolet-B radiation. Frontiers in Plant Science 12:725078. https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC8593374/

Each citation in the paper, for example [1], refers to an item in this list. Each item is a primary source or an instruction from an authority, unless the item shows a different type. The results of cannabis tissue culture change much with the genotype. Before you use the dilutions, hormone doses and local regulations, make sure that they agree with the primary sources.